This event was held in the Appel Room, which is on the 5th & 6th floors of 10 Columbus Circle, above an upscale shopping mall. I like this mall because it's one of the reliable places to find an attractive restroom during business hours -- something that's not obvious in the city.
When I got to the room, I realized that I had been there before. It used to be called the Allen Room. Josh performed there once before -- I think in 2012. That performance was amazing and was shown via simulcast in movie theatres throughout the country.
Google AI says that room seats between 410 and 900 people. I would say it was configured on the low end for this event, because there were tables near the stage. Presumably the tables were the more expensive seats.
The room features a huge window behind the stage overlooking central park and the Manhattan skyline. It's a very beautiful venue.
Even tho the room is not that large, I made heavy use of binoculars, because I was in the back row. I like to sit in the back row because I'm a germaphobe and I don't want people breathing on me.
To get the commemorative program you had to give your credit card and get an auction paddle. You didn't actually have to pay, so I figured that I would do this, thinking I wouldn't participate in the auction.
I only bought this ticket about a week or two before the event. At that time, there were still a lot of seats available, which worried me. By the time I got there, it was pretty much full. I wonder what changed.
There was no announcement not to take pictures or record. There were people recording I think. I did not. I was probably the only person taking notes. Probably you can see some of these performances later on social media
The event opened with a film by Chris Groban, about the mission of FYL.
Then Josh performed the first number: Granted, playing the piano. He had a large band behind him, including 2 backup singers, a pianist, a guitar, 3 percussionists.
Josh's voice sounded great. Those of you who have followed this blog might remember that I haven't always thought he sounded so great -- but he's gotten the kinks out
One of the groups that FYL helps is "Broadway Bound Kids." They sang chorus on Granted and then later did a number of their own
Natalie Tennenbaum, pianist, played variations on Thriller. This was the type of music that originally brought me to Josh -- cross between pop and modern classical. I really loved this piece. I wish Josh would get back to that type of music. She was introduced as the musical director for the performance. That was a bit strange for me, because it's usually Tariqh Akoni, but he was not at this performance -- nor was Mark Stephens, who is usually on piano in Josh's band. It felt like an all new band.
Lin Manuel Miranda did not perform. He just gave a short speech and introduced SAY -- a group for young stutterers. They had a group of four of them come on stage and tell their story. I gather that one of the ways that they get confidence is that various artists/performers come in and work with them, so it's not exactly about them performing. It's the arts as a strengthening of the person, which Josh often talks about.
India Carney, who mostly sang backup, got a solo of "A million dreams" --rich alto voice. Here she is on instagram link.
Joanna “JoJo” Levesque sang a song. Unfortunately, I recognized neither her nor the song, tho I see that she has 2.8 million followers on Instagram link. I did hear a repeated lyric of "Through the Fire," so maybe that was the title of the song? Both Levesque and Carney were heavy on the melisma, which isn't really my thing.
Then Matthew Whitaker, a blind jazz pianist, played a loud rollicking number. I'm not sure why but it sort of reminded me of the music from the Peanuts movies. He was a fun performer.
Josh came back to introduce Misty Copeland, who was identified as the 1st African American prima ballerina at the American Ballet Theater. She is one of those fairly light skinned people who I wouldn't necessarily have identified as "African American" if she hadn't said so. She didn't actually dance, tho. She introduced a group of young dancers from one of the organizations that Find Your Light Supports. They danced.
Josh sang Somewhere over the Rainbow, while Whitacre played the piano and the kids danced. They looked very competent to me -- tho I felt the stage was too small for good dancing. There were two boys and two girls. The dance was unusual because sometimes the boys got lifted by the other dancers -- not just the girls. I think the dance was a ballet, as the dancers pointed their feet a lot -- tho it might have been modern dance. I'm not sure. Here's a link to MOVE NYC on Instagram. Also this post on X has a photo of the 4 dancers
Then arrived Harry Santa Olalla, who is apparently a famous auctioneer. He was a very peppy guy who was able to do a "God Voice" and warm up the room. He started out with a a reverse auction of nothing. He just asked who would agree to pay $50k. After several donations at that level, he asked how many would pay $25k. He gradually lowered it until he got to $500. Josh said he would match any $500 donations, and said "ouch" after anyone raised their paddle, which was rather funny. At that point, I did raise my paddle, which I hadn't expected to -- but Josh really has sold me on the importance of arts education.
I went into that show really depressed, because I am very afraid that Trump is going to win the election -- but by the time we got to the auction I cheered up at the thought of all these kids whose lives have been transformed by arts education, so I got willing to donate. The ticket was $250, so the contribution brought me up to $750, which is a lot of money for me, but I hope it's going to a good cause. I went to the restroom during the auction. I didn't have any trouble getting back in, which has been an issue during the prior concert at the "Allen Room," mostly, I guess, because that was simulcast.
Then they Auctioned off a painting of the statue of Liberty, which an artist made upside down while Josh was singing at Madison Square Garden. Here's a video.
During this auction, Joseph threw in his razor prop from his performance on Broadway from Sweeney Todd. Here I felt he made a strategic error. I think he would have gotten more for the razor on its own. The razor was much smaller, and therefore more attractive as a souvenir. Also the razor would have appealed to a different audience from the painting. I suppose this was likely due to Josh's perennial lack of confidence in his own work, valuing the painting more than the razor, while I suspect many people there would have valued the razor more than the painting.
After the auction, the Broadway Bound Kids performed a song, but I didn't write down the title
The next speaker was Chasten Buttigieg, advocate, teacher, and Broadway aspirant. This is Pete Buttigieg's husband. He talked about his history of having a theater degree and what his arts education brought him, even though he's not now working as an actor. He also introduced Sara Bareilles.
I see that Sara has less followers on Instagram than JoJo Levesque. That's a pity, because I really like Sara. She's one of the few people who Josh has chosen to duet with who I think really sounds good with him. I feel that their voices and their talents are well-matched. Josh has a tendency to think that he can duet with anyone, which isn't quite right. Quite often he chooses altos whose voices aren't well distinguishable from his when they duet. Then, also, his voice is so loud and the audio engineers often don't compensate for that, so you can't hear the woman -- or even sometimes the men. I remember he once performed with Leslie Odom, Jr, who tends to sing quietly and
I think that the song that Bareilles sang solo was "I wanna see you be brave."
Then Sara and Josh did a duet of "Both Sides Now."
Then surgeon general, Vivek Murthy, the Surgeon General of the United States, was given an award for Arts in Healing. He also gave a speech. I have seen him on TV before, but I had no clue what an excellen speaker he is. He talked quite movingly about the role of the arts in his life and his children's lives. He really is an outstanding speaker.
It turns out that he plays an Indian drum in a South Indian classical music style. I think the drum is called a mridangam. He took off his shoes and knelt on the floor to play this instrument, which was an odd thing to see for a distinguished surgeon general. He joked that Josh might have made an error in judgment having him play, but it sounded like he played quite well. Later Josh said he wanted to learn to play like that.
He accompanied Josh and the band in "Peace Train," which was really a wonderful rendition, with *four* percussionists. Josh didn't sing on this one. Vuyo Sotashe did. He sang very beautifully.
Vivek & Josh talked about hitting it off -- "brother from another mother," was what they said -- that they felt like brothers. In a way, I feel they do have similar personalities, at least in the way they present themselves.
Then they had Angel Blue, introduce Renée Fleming, another honoree. Blue is an opera singer, currently at the Met, who did a Puccini aria. I didn't get the title. I often don't like opera singers, but she was very impressive. She sang without a mic and seemingly effortlessly filled the hall with her voice. Josh said that she was in his high school class, which was an impressive fact.
Renée Fleming got a Find Your Light award. She was a lot thinner than I remembered her. She sang a duet of Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah" with Josh. The last time I heard her sign with Josh, she sang as an operatic lyric soprano style. This time was more of an alto belt, but they sounded good together.
Probably I should have taken more pix. I felt shy about doing that since most venues don't allow it, but they didn't say not to in fact.
I just listened to a Facebook video from this concert. https://www.facebook.com/share/r/QE95xwU3zZ4kTqom/?mibextid=UalRPS
Josh absolutely does not sound the same on this video as he did in person. I'm realizing that he's a victim of the same phenomenon that many sopranos suffer from: high frequency clipping. His high harmonics are cut off.
I guess all the times before when I thought something was wrong with his voice it might really have been the recording equipment.